oversharingmuch?
← Learn

Why privacy matters, even if you have nothing to hide

Your data outlives the moment you shared it, and the people in charge of it can change. History shows what happens next.

"I have nothing to hide" is the most common reason people give for not caring about privacy. It assumes two things: that the people who hold your data today mean you well, and that they always will. History says neither is guaranteed.

Everything you share can and will be used

A message, a search, a photo or a question to a chatbot feels temporary. On a company's servers it isn't. It is stored, analysed, used to target ads, used to train AI, and kept for years. The rules about what happens to it can change overnight: Meta started using AI chats to target ads in most countries, with no way to opt out, and OpenAI was ordered by a court to keep chats users had deleted.

Small pieces add up. Your location history shows where you live, work, pray and see a doctor. Your likes and searches reveal your politics, health and sexuality. Together they form a profile more detailed than anything a secret police force of the past could have dreamed of.

George Orwell imagined something like it in his 1949 novel Nineteen Eighty-Four: a "telescreen" in every home that watches and listens, so that nobody knows whether they are being watched at any given moment. The difference today is that no government had to install it. We carry the microphone, the camera and the location tracker ourselves, and the records are kept by companies.

Who holds your data can change

In a stable democracy with independent courts and a free press, the government asking a company for your data is usually limited and checked. But data outlives governments, and governments don't always stay the same.

The Netherlands, 1941

The Netherlands had a detailed, centralised population register, built by a democratic government for ordinary administration. After the German occupation, Jews were ordered to register with their municipality in 1941, and around 160,000 people were recorded (Anne Frank House). Those records became an efficient tool for finding people to deport. Fewer than one in four Dutch Jews survived the Holocaust (Holocaust Encyclopedia).

The resistance understood what the data meant: on 27 March 1943 they bombed and set fire to Amsterdam's population register to try to destroy the records. Only part of it was destroyed, and twelve of those involved were executed (Verzetsmuseum). Today nobody would need to raid a building. The data sits on company servers.

East Germany, until 1989

East Germany's secret police, the Stasi, watched its own citizens through the people around them. By 1989 it had about 189,000 unofficial informers, roughly one for every 90 citizens, who reported on colleagues, friends and classmates, down to "the most intimate information" (Stasi Records Archive). What survives fills more than 111 kilometres of shelves (German Federal Archives). That took an army of people and decades of work. Today a phone and a handful of apps record more about a person's movements, contacts and conversations, automatically.

Afghanistan, 2021

When the Taliban took over, they seized US military biometric devices that, according to US officials, could help identify Afghans who had worked with Western forces. Afghan government databases holding biometric and personal data were also left behind (The Intercept, MIT Technology Review). Data collected for security and ID checks could now be used to find the very people it was collected from.

What authoritarian governments already do

  • China runs a mass surveillance system in Xinjiang that pulls together phone data, movements and personal details to flag people, mostly Uyghurs and other Muslims, for police investigation. Some of those flagged are detained (Human Rights Watch).
  • Iran uses facial recognition, drones and a government app to identify women who don't wear the mandatory headscarf, according to a UN fact-finding mission (CNN).
  • Russia uses facial recognition in the Moscow metro to detain activists and journalists as 'potential protesters', sometimes before any protest has happened (RFE/RL).

In each case the raw material is the same kind of data that apps and platforms collect every day: faces, locations, contacts and messages.

Democracies make mistakes too

It doesn't take a dictatorship. In the Dutch childcare benefits scandal, the tax authority used applicants' nationality in its fraud risk checks and unlawfully kept data on people's dual nationality. The Dutch data protection authority called this discriminatory and unlawful and fined the Tax Administration €2.75 million (Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens). Thousands of families were wrongly labelled as fraudsters.

In Poland, an EU member state, the government disclosed in April 2024 that 578 people had been targeted with Pegasus phone spyware between 2017 and 2022 under its predecessor. A minister said it had been used against "inconvenient politicians, lawyers, judges, prosecutors"; one target was an opposition politician whose phone was hacked during the 2019 election campaign (Notes from Poland).

In the US, a mother's and daughter's Facebook messages were handed to police and used in an abortion-related prosecution in Nebraska. As abortion laws tightened across several US states, messages, searches and period-tracking data became potential evidence. Laws change, and data collected under the old rules can be used under the new ones.

The companies are the pipeline

Governments rarely need to collect this data themselves. They ask the companies that already have it, and companies must comply with legal orders wherever they operate. That is why the most important question on this site is can the company read your data at all? A company that can't read your messages can't hand them over, leak them or sell them, no matter who is in charge.

What you can do

  • Prefer services that can't read your data, such as Signal for messages and Proton for email and files.
  • Keep it at home where you can: run your own AI, photos and files.
  • Share less by default. Skip optional fields, turn off ad personalisation and AI training, and don't tell chatbots anything you wouldn't want on file.
  • Check the score before you trust a company with something personal.