oversharingmuch?

Last reviewed 2 Nov 2026

Proton

Proton Mail, Drive, Pass, VPN and Lumo

Proton is funded by subscriptions, not ads, and most of its products use end-to-end or zero-access encryption, so Proton cannot read your stored emails, files or passwords. Its largest shareholder is a non-profit foundation, and its apps are open source. It is not magic, though: Proton must follow binding Swiss orders, complies with thousands of them each year for account data, and in a few well-known cases the metadata it did have (an IP address, a recovery email) helped police identify activists. In October 2026, reporting that its CEO brushed off security testing to push staff to write more code with AI raised questions about how carefully its software is now built.

Headquarters
Geneva, Switzerland
Jurisdiction
Switzerland
Website
proton.me
Privacy scoreTight-lipped
83/100

Can't read your data even if it wanted to.

What this means for you

  • Proton can't read your stored emails, files or passwords, so it can't hand their contents over, leak them in a breach, or use them for ads.
  • Proton can still access some metadata, such as email subject lines, sender and recipient addresses, a recovery email if you add one, and your IP address if it is ordered to log it.
  • If you need anonymity, not just privacy, don't add a personal recovery email and consider connecting through a VPN or Tor.

Score breakdown

How we score

Apps & products

  • Proton Mail

    Same as the company

    Message bodies and attachments use zero-access encryption. Subject lines and addresses are not end-to-end encrypted, for compatibility with normal email.

  • Proton Drive

    Same as the company

    Files and file names are end-to-end encrypted.

  • Proton Pass

    Same as the company

    Password manager with end-to-end encrypted vaults.

  • Proton VPN

    Same as the company

    No-logs policy checked in five annual independent audits by Securitum.

    Own scoreDiscreet
    76/100

    From company-wide evidence plus evidence about this product.

  • Lumo

    Same as the company

    AI assistant that doesn't train on your chats and keeps saved chat history with zero-access encryption. Your prompts are still processed on Proton's servers to generate answers.

The evidence

Every fact that feeds the score, newest first.

Can they read your data?

Whether your content is end-to-end or zero-access encrypted, so the company itself can't read it.

Emails in Proton Mail are stored with zero-access encryption, so Proton cannot read stored message bodies and attachments.

Emails arriving from non-Proton providers reach Proton's servers readable before being encrypted for storage, and subject lines and addresses are not end-to-end encrypted.

+50 pointsSevereProton Mail
Sources (3)

Business model

How the company makes money. Advertising and data-sharing models reward collecting more about you.

Proton is funded by paid subscriptions and does not show ads or sell user data.

+30 pointsMajor
Sources (2)

Track record

Breaches, scandals and regulator fines, and how the company responded.

Proton's CEO dismissed an employee's request to pentest new code before release as "loser thinking" and pushed staff to write more code with AI, according to a 404 Media investigation that Proton did not dispute.

The reporting, based on eight current and one former employee, Slack messages and meeting audio, describes staff afraid to raise security concerns. Proton said it had sometimes been "too blunt or too slow" in explaining its direction to staff, and the CEO then cancelled planned "re-interviews" that would have made employees justify their AI use. No security incident affecting users has been reported.

-3.4 points (reduced)Minor
Sources (3)

Government & legal requests

What the company hands over to police, courts and governments, and whether it pushes back or reports on it.

Because stored emails, files and passwords are end-to-end or zero-access encrypted, Proton says it cannot decrypt and hand over their contents, even under a legal order.

What Proton can be forced to provide is account data it holds, such as a recovery email address, payment details or, if ordered for a specific account, IP addresses going forward. Unencrypted metadata such as subject lines and sender/recipient addresses may also be at risk.

+30 pointsMajorProton MailProton DriveProton Pass
Sources (3)

Proton complied with 8,313 of 9,301 Swiss legal orders for Proton Mail account data in 2025, and with 10,368 of 11,023 in 2024.

Orders can cover account data Proton holds, such as recovery emails or payment details, not the encrypted content of emails.

-8.0 points (reduced)ModerateProton Mail
Sources (1)

Proton says every legal order for Proton VPN data since 2020 was denied because it keeps no connection logs (59 of 59 in 2025).

+30 pointsMajorProton VPN
Sources (1)

Proton gave Spanish police, via Swiss authorities, the recovery email linked to a Catalan activist's account, which helped identify them.

The recovery address was an iCloud address; Apple then gave Spanish police the identifying details. The request was made as part of a terrorism investigation.

-3.4 points (reduced)MinorProton Mail
Sources (3)

Under a binding Swiss order issued after a French request via Europol, Proton logged the IP address of a French climate activist's account and handed it over; the activist was then arrested.

Proton said it could not appeal that order. In October 2021, Proton won a Swiss court ruling that email services are not telecommunications providers, which exempts them from some data-retention and handover obligations.

-8.0 points (reduced)ModerateProton Mail
Sources (4)

Data collection

How much the company collects, including tracking outside its own products.

Proton VPN needs an account tied to an email address, except on Android, where the free plan can be used as a guest without signing up.

The email address becomes your username and recovery address. Paid plans need an account on every platform.

-8 pointsMinorProton VPN
Sources (3)

Proton's privacy policy says it collects as little user information as possible and does not keep permanent IP logs by default, though IP addresses may be kept temporarily to fight abuse.

+15 pointsModerate
Sources (1)

Proton VPN's no-logs policy has been checked by security firm Securitum in five consecutive annual audits.

+30 pointsMajorProton VPN
Sources (4)

AI & your conversations

Whether your chats, posts and files are used to train AI, reviewed by humans, or kept after you delete them.

Your control

Can you see, export and delete your data, and opt out without dark patterns?

You can usually sign up without a phone number (a CAPTCHA or email check is offered instead) and pay with cash or Bitcoin.

+15 pointsModerate
Sources (2)

Transparency

Open-source code, independent audits and transparency reports.

Proton publishes a transparency report with yearly totals of the legal orders it receives, how many it contested and how many it complied with.

+8 pointsMinor
Sources (1)

Jurisdiction

Which country's laws apply, and how much those laws protect you from surveillance.

Proton only hands over data in response to binding orders from Swiss authorities, and foreign requests must pass Swiss legal-assistance review under Swiss law.

+15 pointsModerate
Sources (3)

A proposed Swiss surveillance rule change (the VÜPF revision) led Proton to start moving some infrastructure out of Switzerland; Lumo was launched on servers in Germany.

In February 2026 the Swiss Federal Council paused the revision after heavy criticism in the consultation and ordered an external impact assessment and a second consultation. Proton says it is not leaving Switzerland.

-4.2 points (reduced)MinorLumo
Sources (4)

First published 3 Nov 2026