How we score
Every score on this site is calculated, never typed in by hand. We collect documented facts about a company, such as a regulator's fine, an encryption feature, or a court order, and each fact moves one category of the score up or down. The numbers below come straight from the code that calculates the scores, so this page can't drift out of date.
What counts as evidence
- One claim, one fact. Each piece of evidence is a single factual sentence with a date.
- Always sourced. Every claim links to at least one source. Primary sources (regulator and court decisions, the company's own policies, transparency reports and blog posts) count fully. Reputable journalism counts slightly less.
- Archived. Where possible we link a Wayback Machine snapshot, because privacy policies change quietly.
- Fixed issues still count, for less. A breach that was fixed still happened, but it matters less than one that is still going on.
What we don't do
- We don't accept money, ads or affiliate links from the companies we rate.
- We don't usually score products separately. Trust is a property of the company: the same data pool, the same privacy policy and the same legal exposure. Apps are listed under their company, with a note when one is clearly better or worse. The exception is a product that competes in a category where the rest of the company's evidence doesn't apply, such as Proton VPN among VPNs. It gets its own score there, built from company-wide evidence plus evidence about that product, so encrypted email doesn't lift a VPN's rating.
- We don't guess. If we have no evidence for a category, it is left out rather than assumed to be good or bad.