oversharingmuch?

Last reviewed 29 Sept 2026

Meta

Facebook, Instagram, WhatsApp, Messenger and Meta AI

Meta earns almost all of its money from advertising, and its products are built to learn as much about you as possible to target those ads. WhatsApp and Messenger encrypt personal message content end to end, which is a real protection, but everything else you do on Facebook and Instagram is collected, and since December 2025 your conversations with Meta AI are also used to personalise ads in most countries. Meta has faced some of the largest privacy fines and settlements on record, including a $5 billion FTC penalty and a €1.2 billion GDPR fine.

Headquarters
Menlo Park, California
Jurisdiction
United States
Privacy scoreOversharer
20/100

Treats your data as widely available.

What this means for you

  • Assume anything you post, like, watch or search on Facebook or Instagram becomes part of an advertising profile about you.
  • WhatsApp can't read your messages, but it does know who you talk to and when, and an FBI document shows it can hand that to US police in near real time (every 15 minutes) with a court order.
  • Don't tell Meta AI anything you wouldn't want used to pick the ads you see. Outside the EU, UK and South Korea there is no opt-out, and humans may review your chats.
  • Meta's tracking pixel is embedded on millions of other websites, so it can learn about you even when you're not on Facebook.

Better alternatives

More private options for the same job.

Score breakdown

How we score

Apps & products

  • Facebook

    Same as the company

    The core of Meta's ad business. Posts, likes, groups, searches and viewing behaviour all feed ad targeting.

  • Instagram

    Same as the company

    Same data practices and ad system as Facebook. Meta removed the option for end-to-end encrypted Instagram DMs in May 2026.

  • WhatsApp

    Better than the company overall

    Message content is end-to-end encrypted by default using the Signal protocol. Metadata (who, when, how often) is still available to Meta and to law enforcement.

  • Messenger

    Better than the company overall

    Meta began making personal (one-to-one) chats end-to-end encrypted by default in December 2023; group chats are still opt-in.

  • Meta AI

    Worse than the company overall

    Conversations are not end-to-end encrypted, may be reviewed by humans including contractors, and since 16 December 2025 are used to personalise content and ads in most countries, with no opt-out.

The evidence

Every fact that feeds the score, newest first.

Can they read your data?

Whether your content is end-to-end or zero-access encrypted, so the company itself can't read it.

Everything you post, like, search and watch on Facebook and Instagram is stored in a form Meta can read and use for ad targeting.

-50 pointsSevereFacebookInstagram
Sources (1)

Meta removed the option of end-to-end encrypted Instagram direct messages, so it can technically access the content of all Instagram DMs again.

The opt-in encrypted chats, introduced in December 2023 in some regions, were shut down on 8 May 2026. Meta cited low adoption and pointed users to WhatsApp. Meta says DMs are not used to train its AI.

-12 pointsModerateInstagram
Sources (3)

WhatsApp messages are end-to-end encrypted by default, so Meta cannot read their content.

Rolled out to all users by 5 April 2016 using the Signal Protocol. Exceptions: messages a user reports are sent to WhatsApp, and chats with businesses or Meta AI may be handled differently. A January 2026 US class action alleges Meta staff and contractors could access messages; Meta calls this 'false and absurd' and it is unproven.

+30 pointsMajorWhatsApp
Sources (4)

Business model

How the company makes money. Advertising and data-sharing models reward collecting more about you.

Track record

Breaches, scandals and regulator fines, and how the company responded.

A New Mexico jury found that Meta violated the state's Unfair Practices Act by misleading users about privacy, including what it let third-party apps do with their data, in a case that grew out of the Cambridge Analytica scandal. Penalties have not yet been set.

The jury found more than 43 million violations. Meta disagreed with the verdict and said it would continue to defend itself.

-24 pointsMajorFacebook
Sources (2)

Meta stored hundreds of millions of user passwords in plain text on internal systems and was fined €91 million.

Discovered and disclosed in 2019. Meta estimated it affected hundreds of millions of Facebook Lite users, tens of millions of other Facebook users and tens of thousands of Instagram users. The passwords were not exposed outside Meta.

-7.5 pointsModerateFacebookInstagramFixed 21 Mar 2019

Meta said it fixed the issue after discovering it in 2019 and found no evidence of abuse.

Sources (3)

Meta agreed to pay Texas $1.4 billion, over five years, to settle a lawsuit alleging it captured facial-recognition data from users' photos without consent. Meta did not admit wrongdoing.

Texas sued under its biometric privacy law (CUBI) over Facebook's discontinued 'tag suggestions' feature. Settlement signed 29 July 2024 and entered by the court 30 July 2024; $500 million was due in the first payment. Meta maintained it complied with the law.

-50 pointsSevereFacebook
Sources (4)

Ireland's regulator, bound by an EU (EDPB) decision, fined Meta €1.2 billion, the largest GDPR fine to date, for unlawfully transferring Europeans' Facebook data to the United States.

Meta is appealing and the fine is currently stayed by the Irish High Court. In February 2026 the EU's top court ruled that Meta can also challenge the EDPB decision directly at the EU courts.

-50 pointsSevereFacebook
Sources (4)

Phone numbers and profile data of about 533 million Facebook users were scraped and published online; Ireland's regulator fined Meta €265 million.

Scraped through Facebook's search and contact-importer tools between 2018 and 2019 and leaked on a hacking forum in April 2021. The DPC found breaches of data protection by design and default. Meta is challenging the decision in the Irish High Court.

-50 pointsSevereFacebook
Sources (3)

Ireland fined Meta €405 million over Instagram publicly exposing some children's phone numbers and email addresses (via business accounts) and setting children's personal accounts to public by default.

The exposure came from teenagers who switched to Instagram business accounts, which showed contact details publicly. The EDPB required a higher fine and an extra finding. Meta said it would appeal.

-30 pointsMajorInstagram
Sources (3)

Data on up to 87 million Facebook users was harvested by a quiz app and passed to Cambridge Analytica without their consent; the FTC imposed a then-record $5 billion penalty on Facebook.

The FTC found Facebook had violated a 2012 privacy order and imposed a $5 billion penalty and new oversight in a 2019 settlement. Meta later paid $725 million to settle a US class action (2022). In September 2026 a New Mexico jury found Facebook had deceived users about privacy in this case; penalties are still to be set.

-50 pointsSevereFacebook
Sources (2)

Government & legal requests

What the company hands over to police, courts and governments, and whether it pushes back or reports on it.

WhatsApp can give US law enforcement a target's message metadata (who they message and when) every 15 minutes in response to a pen register order.

Revealed by an internal FBI document dated January 2021 and published by Rolling Stone. A WhatsApp spokesperson confirmed the near-real-time responses but said they are forward-looking only, never include message content, and require valid legal process.

-24 pointsMajorWhatsApp
Sources (2)

Data collection

How much the company collects, including tracking outside its own products.

The Meta Pixel sent sensitive medical information from some US hospital websites to Facebook, including details of patients' appointments and conditions.

The Markup found the pixel on the websites of 33 of Newsweek's top 100 US hospitals, sending data when visitors booked appointments. The hospitals installed the pixel; US regulators (FTC and HHS) later warned hospitals about these trackers. Meta faces class actions over this.

-30 pointsMajorFacebook
Sources (3)

AI & your conversations

Whether your chats, posts and files are used to train AI, reviewed by humans, or kept after you delete them.

Since 16 December 2025, Meta uses your conversations with Meta AI to personalise ads and content in most countries (not the EU, UK or South Korea), with no way to opt out except not using Meta AI.

-50 pointsSevereMeta AI
Sources (3)

The Meta AI app's public "Discover" feed showed conversations that many users apparently didn't realise they were publishing, including medical and legal questions.

Chats were private by default and had to be 'shared' to appear, but the sharing flow was confusing. Meta later added a warning that posted prompts are public.

-12 pointsModerateMeta AI
Sources (3)

Meta trains its AI models on public posts and comments from adult users in the EU, with an objection form as the only way to opt out.

Announced 14 April 2025; training began 27 May 2025, also using people's interactions with Meta AI. A German court (Higher Regional Court of Cologne) refused an injunction on 23 May 2025. Outside the EU, Meta already trained on public posts without an objection form in most countries.

-15 pointsModerateFacebookInstagramMeta AI
Sources (3)

Your control

Can you see, export and delete your data, and opt out without dark patterns?

You can download a copy of your data and manage much of it through Accounts Center.

+8 pointsMinorFacebookInstagram
Sources (1)

The European Commission fined Meta €200 million because its "pay or consent" model didn't give users a real choice to use Facebook and Instagram with less personal data.

Decision of 23 April 2025 under the Digital Markets Act, covering March–November 2024. Meta appealed to the EU General Court on 4 July 2025. After Meta committed to a 'less personalised ads' option from January 2026, the Commission called it 'a very good step forward' in December 2025.

-30 pointsMajorFacebookInstagram
Sources (3)

Ireland fined Meta €390 million for unlawfully relying on its terms of service ('contract') to show Facebook and Instagram users personalised ads, which effectively made accepting them a condition of using the services.

€210 million for Facebook and €180 million for Instagram. The DPC also found transparency breaches. Meta appealed.

-24 pointsMajorFacebookInstagram
Sources (3)

Transparency

Open-source code, independent audits and transparency reports.

Jurisdiction

Which country's laws apply, and how much those laws protect you from surveillance.

As a US company, Meta can be compelled under US law, including the CLOUD Act, to hand over data it holds, wherever it is stored.

-15 pointsModerate
Sources (1)

First published 3 Nov 2026