What a government can demand
Anything a company can read, a court or government can order it to hand over, sometimes without you ever finding out.
Big tech companies receive large numbers of government requests for user data every year, many of them from criminal investigations. But the rule is simple: if a company can read your data, it can be forced to hand it over.
Messages that weren't encrypted
In 2022, Meta handed Nebraska police the Facebook messages between a mother and her teenage daughter under a warrant. The messages were later used in a prosecution related to an abortion. Meta said the warrants didn't mention abortion and came with non-disclosure orders that stopped it from talking about them (NPR, Meta). Messenger chats weren't end-to-end encrypted by default at the time. Personal Messenger chats are now: Meta started switching them over in December 2023 (Meta).
Metadata is often enough
Even when message content is encrypted, metadata (who you talk to, when, and from where) often isn't. According to an internal FBI document from 2021, WhatsApp can tell police who a target messages, and when, every 15 minutes in response to a pen register order. The content of the messages isn't included.
Even privacy companies must comply
Privacy-focused companies still have to follow the law where they're based. Proton, for example, has handed over an IP address and a recovery email to police after Swiss legal orders (details). The difference is that Proton can't hand over the contents of your stored emails, because they're encrypted with keys it doesn't have. (Subject lines and addresses aren't protected the same way.)
Where a company is based matters
US companies can be compelled under laws like the CLOUD Act to hand over data they control, even if it's stored in another country. Other countries offer stronger or weaker protection, and laws change.
What you can do
- Prefer end-to-end encryption for messages, files and backups, so there's nothing readable to hand over.
- Minimise metadata. Don't link a personal recovery email or phone number to accounts that need to stay anonymous.
- Check transparency reports. Companies that publish how many requests they get, and how often they push back, earn points in our transparency category.