oversharingmuch?

Last reviewed 29 Sept 2026

Apple

iPhone, Mac, iCloud, iMessage, Siri and Apple Intelligence

Apple makes most of its money selling hardware, not ads, and privacy is a big part of how it sells that hardware. iMessage and FaceTime are end-to-end encrypted, much processing happens on your device, and App Tracking Transparency made it much harder for apps to follow you. But by default many kinds of iCloud data, including backups and Photos, are not end-to-end encrypted, so Apple holds the keys and can hand that data over in response to a warrant. The stronger option, Advanced Data Protection, is off by default and has been unavailable to new UK users since 2025, after a reported government demand for access.

Headquarters
Cupertino, California
Jurisdiction
United States
Privacy scoreChatty
55/100

Shares more about you than you'd probably like.

What this means for you

  • Turn on Advanced Data Protection (Settings → your name → iCloud). Without it, Apple can read and hand over your iCloud backups, photos and notes.
  • iMessage and FaceTime are end-to-end encrypted, but if your iCloud backup isn't, copies of your messages in that backup can still be read.
  • Apple Intelligence runs on your device or on Apple's Private Cloud Compute, which Apple says is designed so it can't keep or see your requests. If you turn on the optional ChatGPT integration, requests you send to ChatGPT go to OpenAI.

Better alternatives

More private options for the same job.

Score breakdown

How we score

Apps & products

  • iCloud

    Worse than the company overall

    Backups, Photos, iCloud Drive, Notes and several other categories are only end-to-end encrypted if you turn on Advanced Data Protection, which is off by default and not available to new users in the UK.

  • iMessage & FaceTime

    Better than the company overall

    End-to-end encrypted by default.

  • Siri

    Same as the company

    Audio recordings are only kept and reviewed (by Apple employees) if you opt in; Apple changed this in 2019 after it emerged that contractors were listening to recordings.

  • Apple Intelligence

    Better than the company overall

    Runs on-device or on Private Cloud Compute, which is designed not to retain your data. ChatGPT integration is opt-in.

  • iPhone & iOS

    Same as the company

    App Tracking Transparency makes apps ask before tracking you across other companies' apps and websites.

The evidence

Every fact that feeds the score, newest first.

Can they read your data?

Whether your content is end-to-end or zero-access encrypted, so the company itself can't read it.

iMessage and FaceTime are end-to-end encrypted by default, so Apple can't read them.

This covers messages in transit. If iCloud Backup is on without Advanced Data Protection, the backup holds a key to Messages in iCloud, so Apple can access message copies stored there.

+30 pointsMajoriMessage & FaceTime
Sources (4)

Advanced Data Protection extends end-to-end encryption to iCloud backups, photos, notes and more, but it is off by default.

Without it, Apple holds the keys to many iCloud categories, including device backups (which can contain copies of your messages), Photos, iCloud Drive and Notes. Some categories, such as passwords and Health data, are end-to-end encrypted either way.

-30 pointsMajoriCloud
Sources (3)

Business model

How the company makes money. Advertising and data-sharing models reward collecting more about you.

Apple earns most of its revenue from hardware; advertising is a small part of its business.

In fiscal 2025 Apple reported $416.2bn in net sales: iPhone $209.6bn, Mac/iPad/Wearables about $97bn, Services $109.2bn. Advertising sits inside Services and is not reported separately; outside estimates put Apple's own ad revenue in the single-digit billions. Services also includes payments from Google for Safari's default search engine, which are funded by Google's advertising.

+30 pointsMajor
Sources (4)

Track record

Breaches, scandals and regulator fines, and how the company responded.

Contractors listened to samples of Siri recordings, including accidental activations, as part of Apple's quality 'grading' program; Apple later agreed to pay $95 million to settle a class action over Siri recordings, without admitting wrongdoing.

-7.5 pointsModerateSiriFixed 28 Aug 2019

Apple apologised, stopped keeping recordings by default and made human review opt-in. It did not admit wrongdoing in the settlement.

Sources (4)

Government & legal requests

What the company hands over to police, courts and governments, and whether it pushes back or reports on it.

Apple can hand over iCloud data that isn't protected by Advanced Data Protection when it receives a valid legal request.

Apple's US Legal Process Guidelines say iCloud content, including photos, iCloud Drive, Messages and device backups, may be provided in response to a search warrant. With ADP on, only limited data such as mail, contacts and calendars remains available.

-30 pointsMajoriCloud
Sources (4)

Apple stopped offering Advanced Data Protection to new UK users after the UK government reportedly served it with a secret order under the Investigatory Powers Act demanding access to encrypted iCloud data. Apple says it has never built a backdoor and is challenging the demand at the Investigatory Powers Tribunal.

Existing UK users were told they would eventually have to turn ADP off. The UK reportedly dropped its first notice in 2025 after US objections, then issued a second one in October 2025 aimed at British users. Apple filed a new complaint at the Investigatory Powers Tribunal in mid-2026, and ADP is still unavailable to new UK users.

-15 pointsModerateiCloud
Sources (4)

Data collection

How much the company collects, including tracking outside its own products.

Apple processes much of your data on-device and designs services to collect less; for example, Maps and Siri requests are tied to random identifiers rather than your Apple Account.

+15 pointsModerate
Sources (2)

AI & your conversations

Whether your chats, posts and files are used to train AI, reviewed by humans, or kept after you delete them.

Apple Intelligence runs on-device or on Private Cloud Compute, servers designed so that requests aren't stored and can be verified by outside researchers.

Apple has published PCC software images, parts of the source code and a Virtual Research Environment for outside researchers. Requests you choose to send to the optional ChatGPT integration are not processed by PCC.

+30 pointsMajorApple Intelligence
Sources (5)

Your control

Can you see, export and delete your data, and opt out without dark patterns?

App Tracking Transparency requires apps to ask permission before tracking you across other companies' apps and websites.

Competition regulators in France (EUR 150 million, 2025) and Italy (EUR 98.6 million, December 2025) fined Apple over how it implemented ATT, finding it disadvantaged other developers. Those decisions were about competition, not about ATT failing to protect privacy.

+30 pointsMajoriPhone & iOS
Sources (4)

Transparency

Open-source code, independent audits and transparency reports.

Jurisdiction

Which country's laws apply, and how much those laws protect you from surveillance.

First published 3 Nov 2026